The Hedgehog and the Chameleon: Should Water Professionals Specialize or Adapt?

By Tyson Scott, Senior Search Consultant at Hunter Crown


Jack of All Trades or Master of One?

In his essay The Hedgehog and the Fox, philosopher Isaiah Berlin references an ancient Greek saying:

"The fox knows many things, but the hedgehog knows one big thing."

The fox uses countless different tricks to hunt and stay safe, while the hedgehog relies on just one, really good trick.

Jim Collins used the hedgehog concept in his book Good to Great. He argues that great organizations succeed by focusing on the intersection of three things: what they can be the best at, what they're passionate about, and what drives their economic engine.

Find your strength, focus on it, become the best at it. Makes sense, right?

But what happens when ideas or technology disrupt your specialty? What happens when the one thing you've mastered is no longer what the market needs?

You have to adapt or risk becoming obsolete.

Enter the chameleon.

While the hedgehog represents the importance of specialization, the chameleon represents adaptability. It adjusts to a changing environment rather than depending entirely on one single approach.

And perhaps the real advantage isn't choosing one over the other. It could mean knowing when to be a hedgehog and when to be a chameleon.

Remember Blockbuster?

For some of us, it would have been hard to imagine a world without video rental stores.

Blockbuster had built an empire around something we all loved: watching movies at home. They knew their business, understood their customers, and had become a household name.

Then came Netflix.

What's interesting is that Netflix didn't start out as the streaming leader we know today. It started with renting DVDs through the mail.

In many ways, Netflix was a hedgehog. It found something it could do exceptionally well and built a business around it.

But as technology evolved and watching habits shifted, Netflix recognized that the way people wanted to watch movies was changing. So it changed too.

Netflix went from delivering DVDs to delivering digital entertainment, and eventually to creating the entertainment itself with original programming.

It started as a hedgehog but knew when to become a chameleon.

Blockbuster, on the other hand, had mastered the legacy video rental business. And while it made attempts to adapt, it remained too dependent on the model that had made it successful in the first place.

Here's the interesting part: people never stopped watching movies. We just started watching them differently.

Netflix understood that its business wasn't really about DVDs. It was about giving people access to entertainment.

Blockbuster had become exceptionally good at one way of solving that problem. Netflix recognized that the problem remained the same, even when the solution changed.

It's an interesting lesson, especially when you consider how we approach our careers.

A Mile Wide or a Mile Deep?

Think about how diverse the water and wastewater industry really is.

Municipal drinking water, industrial wastewater, desalination, biological treatment, membrane filtration, PFAS remediation, water reuse, odor control, and countless other applications all fall under one giant umbrella. Now think about all the sub-specializations within those sectors.

An engineer might spend an entire career mastering dry and wet scrubbers, while another moves between valves, filtration, chemical processes, and project management.

The specialist (hedgehog) in this example likely possesses a level of technical expertise that's difficult to replace. When something goes wrong, they're the subject matter expert everyone calls.

The generalist (chameleon), on the other hand, may understand how different technologies interact, identify opportunities across industries, and adapt more easily when priorities shift.

Both come with value and risks.

The specialist risks becoming too dependent on one area of expertise. The generalist risks knowing a little about everything without becoming exceptional at anything.

And in an industry where technologies, regulations, and customer needs continue to evolve, both face an interesting challenge.

How do you become exceptionally good at something without becoming so dependent on it that you struggle when things change?

The Case for Being Both

Specialization leads to credibility. It allows professionals to develop deep knowledge, solve difficult problems, and distinguish themselves as subject matter experts in a competitive industry.

Adaptability leads to longevity. It allows those same professionals to recognize changing demands, learn new technologies, and remain valuable as the industry evolves.

Perhaps the strongest careers are built by combining both.

Think about a membrane specialist who understands the broader challenges of water treatment, or a process engineer who develops strong leadership and sales skills.

They aren't abandoning their specialties. They're expanding what they can do with them. And that is an important distinction. 

A professional who builds a career around understanding and solving complex water treatment challenges has a foundation that can evolve with the industry. Someone who defines their expertise entirely around one particular technology may find it more difficult to adapt when a different solution becomes the preferred approach.

Specialize in the problems you solve, not just the technologies you use to solve them.

That's where the hedgehog and the chameleon can work together.

So, Which One Are You?

There's nothing wrong with becoming the world's leading expert in a niche field. There's also value in expanding your professional knowledge and understanding a variety of disciplines.

Innovation and growth in the water and wastewater industry will never stand still. Anyone who attends WEFTEC can see this at every turn. New technologies emerge, regulations change, and approaches that once seemed cutting-edge eventually become standard practice or give way to something better.

There's a lot to be said for mastering your craft, but there's also something to be said for recognizing when it's time to expand beyond it.

Consider whether the skills you're developing today will allow you to remain valuable tomorrow.

The water industry will always need people who understand how to solve complex water challenges. The tools, technologies, and approaches used to solve them, however, will continue to change.

So develop your expertise. Become the person people turn to. Figure out the one thing you can do exceptionally well.

Just don't become so attached to how you've always done it that you miss what's coming next.

There's nothing wrong with being a hedgehog. Just know when it's time to be a chameleon.


Contact Us